"At one point, I went to a community event for kids and ended up sitting alongside another politician. He was grasping a pile of 100 baht notes to hand out to the children, whereas I had come without gifts. How was I supposed to compete with that?"
Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was part of the "idealistic tide" of idealistic young candidates who shocked Thailand in the 2023 election by winning more seats for the forward-thinking movement than any other party.
However, in the latest election, he was defeated in his seat in his home province of Rayong to a challenger from an long-standing political dynasty which has customarily controlled leadership roles there.
"In 2023 we were like a storm that overwhelmed and the rival factions weren't ready to respond. They believed I was just a no-name candidate. The wave of support for Move Forward in the closing stages of that election truly encouraged voters to experiment with change."
Now re-branded the People's Party, their hopes that they would surpass their 2023 performance were dashed on the reefs of entrenched clientelist systems which have controlled regional politics in Thailand during its modern history.
The outcomes are not yet official, and a series of election issues are being investigated, but that will not alter the final picture: a sharp drop of over 20% in the total of seats gained by the People's Party, and a notable rise by the traditionalist Bhumjaithai party, boosting its share of seats from 71 in 2023 to an estimated 193 in the 500-seat parliament in the latest election.
'They ceased to address me again'
Following gaining his seat in 2023, Chutiphong dedicated himself to his role as MP, travelling around his district aiming to tackle the issues encountered by his voters. But he swiftly met resistance from those working for the established political operators. Furthermore, he found he was pressured to donate generously, from funds he simply did not have.
"An invitation was extended to me to a female empowerment event - a common function for the residents to participate in and enjoy themselves. But they informed me if I desired to come, I must give 25,000 baht. I responded I did not possess that money. They were quite displeased about that and remarked I was unfeeling. I questioned if there was an alternative I could do to help out. But they ignored me again."
What he had encountered was a deep-rooted framework of patronage controlled by a particular family.
Rayong is primarily recognized as within the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's largest manufacturing hub, containing many of the factories which power its trade-reliant economy. This has brought in outside workers from across the country, and also led to an urban middle class which is more open to the progressive policies of the reformist groups.
In 2023, Move Forward secured all five electoral districts there.
But a lot of Rayong is still rural, the domain of agricultural workers and orchard owners. This is notably the case in District 4, where Chutipong secured his seat. He is a native son, but spent several years living in California. The province has for a long time been dominated by a prominent local household, the Pitutecha family. This is what is referred to in Thailand as "Big House" – big house – politics, and across the country it is the way local power has traditionally been exercised.
Pitutechas control a large part of the regional authority.
Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the sitting patriarch, is the selected chief of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a hugely powerful role as the PAO controls the bulk of public funds in Rayong.
Prior to 2023, Pitutechas had invariably been counted among the MPs chosen to parliament, with one being the assistant health secretary in Bangkok.
Like other "Baan Yai" clans they have no strong affiliation – over time they have stood for several political parties. They are also influential in the local business community, and, unlike Chutipong, have plenty of money to dispense. It was almost hopeless for the new MP to challenge.
The "Baan Yai" depend on widespread systems of campaign workers - residents who are familiar with their villages, and who rally voters to back their candidate. And while it is formally prohibited, they also hand out money during and after elections. They have traditionally been critical to the electoral performance of regional candidates, and as a novel, predominantly urban organisation, the People's Party had did not possess them.
"So I modified my strategy," says Chutipong. "I declared that I would try to address all complaints right away. If your water doesn't run, your electricity has failed, your road has damage, I would assist."
"But the locals who called me in then experienced coercion from the local machine. Some got chastised in the village's chat group or over the PA system in the village. They were charged of introducing me - a stranger they said - into the area."
"On occasions when I tried to inspect factories after getting some allegations about pollution, I faced a negative reaction from local communities because they had been receiving payments from these factories."
By the time of the recent electoral contest, the Pitutechas had adjusted following their defeat in the last election.
In those electoral areas, they nominated younger members of the family, more qualified and with less of old-guard reputation than the established figures. In District 3 they campaigned under the Democrat party, historically their chosen political partner, but in District 4, thirty-four-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha campaigned under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, known for its deep pockets and its ability in winning "Big House" to his side.
Chutipong was outmatched.
The Pitutechas recaptured both seats back from the People's Party, although the reformists retained three seats in Rayong.
"They might have welcomed me if I had given them money, but I was unable to do that permanently due to my limited resources. I had to decide whether I would be the MP they expected, or if I would maintain my values and see if the voters would